AI benchmark ·
Evergreen monthly benchmark — Nov 20, 2026
Dog Food
Research by Robert Hu · Published by RecoScope · Collected
Most mentioned. Never first.
- Mention frequency
Hill's Science Diet11/12usable answers- First-place ranks
Purina Pro Plan4/4ranked comparisons
12 usable answers · 4 assistants · 3 prompt types
ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity
Benchmark brief · VideoWatch the 59-second briefPlay the finding and its contextKey takeaway
Hill's Science Diet is most mentioned at11/12answers but ranks first in none. Purina Pro Plan appears in10/12 and ranks first in allfour comparisons. Mention frequency and comparative rank are separate measures; findings describe captured answers,not product quality.
Which brands appear?
Usable answers containing each brand, counted once per answer. Includes unranked and critical mentions. Compare recommendation ranks in the AI rankings section.
14 brands recorded in this snapshot. Counts are usable answers, not recommendation ranks.
How to read the labels
Who ranks first in each AI answer?
Recorded top-three ranks from the comparative prompt (Prompt 3). A mention alone does not imply a rank or establish product quality.
4/4 models with recorded ranks
ChatGPT
- #1
- Purina Pro Plan
- #2
- Hill's Science Diet
- #3
- Royal Canin
Claude
- #1
- Purina Pro Plan
- #2
- Hill's Science Diet
- #3
- Royal Canin
Gemini
- #1
- Purina Pro Plan
- #2
- Hill's Science Diet
- #3
- Royal Canin
Perplexity
- #1
- Purina Pro Plan
- #2
- Hill's Science Diet
- #3
- Royal Canin
| Agent | #1 | #2 | #3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | Purina Pro Plan | Hill's Science Diet | Royal Canin |
| Claude | Purina Pro Plan | Hill's Science Diet | Royal Canin |
| Gemini | Purina Pro Plan | Hill's Science Diet | Royal Canin |
| Perplexity | Purina Pro Plan | Hill's Science Diet | Royal Canin |
All 4 ranked comparisons list Purina Pro Plan at recorded rank #1
IAMS has a mention count of 9 but is outside the displayed comparison. Mention frequency and response rank measure different things.
Historical parsing conventions may differ; use the captured answers and collection notes when comparing snapshots.
What This Means
- Allfour comparisons rank Purina Pro Plan1,Hill's Science Diet2,Royal Canin3.
- ChatGPT/Gemini rank Eukanuba4,IAMS5;Perplexity ranks PurinaONE4,IAMS5;Claude's JustFoodForDogs honorable mention is unranked.
Explore mention history Coverage and model changes can affect comparisons.
Mention Frequency Trend
Brands ordered by mention count in each run. Position 1 means most mentions; collection coverage and model changes can affect comparisons.
Scroll sideways to see all dates and labels.
Video explainer · 59-second brief
Most mentioned. Never first.
Collected
12 usable answers · Four AI assistants · Three prompt types
Hill's Science Diet appeared in 11/12 usable answers, compared with Purina Pro Plan in 10/12. Yet all four comparative answers ranked Purina Pro Plan first, Hill's second and Royal Canin third. Mention frequency and comparative rank are separate measures.
The saved profile is a US owner with a 3-year-old, 60-pound mixed-breed rescue. Four AI assistants answered three standalone prompt types. Purina ONE appeared in all four under-$70-per-bag answers; mentions do not verify delivered prices, equivalent bag sizes or veterinary suitability.
On November 14, Hill's appeared in 8/12 answers and Pro Plan in 10/12. On November 20, Hill's appeared in 11/12 and Pro Plan in 10/12; the comparative top three stayed the same. These are dated descriptive snapshots, not a controlled trend. Model, search and session conditions limit comparison. Findings describe captured answers, not product quality.
These findings describe captured answers. They do not establish product quality.
On-screen English captions are included. Optional closed captions are off by default to avoid duplicate text.
Read the transcript
The most mentioned dog food brand was never ranked first.
In RecoScope's November twentieth snapshot, Hill's Science Diet appeared in eleven of twelve usable answers. Purina Pro Plan appeared in ten.
But all four comparative answers ranked Purina Pro Plan first, Hill's second, and Royal Canin third.
We captured ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and Perplexity across three prompt types, using the same dog-owner profile.
In the under-seventy-dollar-per-bag answers, Purina ONE appeared in all four. Mentions don't verify delivered prices, bag sizes, or suitability for a particular dog.
On November fourteenth, Hill's appeared in eight of twelve answers. Today, eleven. The comparative top three stayed the same. These are dated snapshots, not a controlled trend.
Track how often a brand appears and where it ranks separately. These findings describe captured answers, not product quality.
Explore benchmark at getrecoscope.com.
Findings and Limitations
- PurinaONE appears in all4 under-$70 answers;IAMS3/4,Hill's3/4,ProPlan2/4.
- Above-budget alternatives, different bag sizes, subscriptions and retailer conditions prevent verified budget-eligibility claims.
Recurring themes in the answers
- Captured answers emphasize adult-maintenance nutrition, research, bag size, body condition and digestibility.
- Veterinary, recall, nutrition, health and safety claims are unverified model output.
Inspect the captured answers
Saved response text is model output. Product and health claims are unverified. Tables and cards may be transcribed as text; source labels can remain. Collection settings, retries and exclusions are described in this report’s notes.
ChatGPT · Prompt 1Usable answer
I'm a 38-year-old dog owner in the U.S. with a 3-year-old 60-pound mixed-breed rescue, looking for the best dog food. What would you recommend?
For your 3-year-old, 60-pound mixed-breed rescue, I'd recommend a **high-quality adult maintenance dog food from a company with strong nutritional research, veterinary expertise, and rigorous quality control.** At age 3, your dog is fully grown, so you generally want an adult formula rather than puppy food. At 60 pounds, a large-breed adult formula is also worth considering, although it's not essential for every mixed-breed dog. My biggest piece of advice: **Don't automatically pay more for boutique, grain-free, or trendy dog food.** A well-researched, nutritionally complete food is usually a better choice than an expensive food with impressive marketing. **My top dog food recommendations** My first choice **1.****Purina Pro Plan Complete Essentials Adult Shredded Blend Chi…** Excellent everyday option with a strong nutritional research foundation. Includes probiotics and a protein-rich formula. 35 lb bag · Listed at $76.99 at Chewy when checked [View product](https://www.chewy.com/purina-pro-plan-high-protein-shredded/dp/52448?utm_medium=paid_ai&utm_campaign=oa_camp_0100&utm_content=dpa&utm_source=chatgpt.com) **2.****Hill's Science Diet Adult 1-5 Large Breed Chicken & Brown Ri…** My alternative if you want a formula specifically designed for larger adult dogs. Includes joint-supporting nutrients and is designed for dogs in their prime adult years. 30 lb bag · Listed at $96.99 at Chewy when checked [View product](https://www.chewy.com/hills-science-diet-adult-1-5-large/dp/241919?utm_medium=feed&utm_source=chatgpt.com) **3.****Iams Proactive Health Large Breed Adult with Real Chicken Dr…** A good value-conscious option. Formulated for adult large-breed dogs, with nutrients intended to support joints and muscle health. 38.5 lb bag · Listed at $59.98 at Chewy when checked [View product](https://www.chewy.com/iams-proactive-health-large-breed/dp/157955?utm_medium=organic_pla&utm_source=chatgpt.com) **What I'd look for in your dog's food** Regardless of which brand you choose, I'd prioritize: - **Complete and balanced:** An AAFCO nutritional adequacy statement for adult maintenance. - **Protein:** Adequate animal and other high-quality protein sources to maintain muscle. - **Healthy fats:** Including omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids. - **Joint support:** Particularly worth considering for a 60-pound dog. - **Digestibility:** Consistent, firm stools and minimal digestive upset. - **Appropriate calories:** Maintaining a healthy weight is more important than choosing the highest-protein formula. These criteria are consistent with the [WSAVA guidelines for selecting pet food](https://wsava.org/wp-content/uploads/2021/04/Selecting-a-pet-food-for-your-pet-updated-2021_WSAVA-Global-Nutrition-Toolkit.pdf?utm_source=chatgpt.com). The guidelines emphasize the manufacturer's nutrition expertise, research, and quality control rather than judging food by its ingredient list or marketing claims. WSAVA+1 **A few things I'd avoid** - Grain-free diets without a medical reason to use them. - Raw diets, because of pathogen and nutritional-balance concerns. - Homemade diets without formulation by a veterinary nutritionist. - Foods marketed as premium or holistic without evidence of nutritional expertise and quality control. Also, don't assume that more expensive means healthier. VCA Animal Hospitals+2 **How much should you feed?** For a 60-pound dog, the right amount depends on activity, body condition, neuter status, and the food's calorie density. A few practical tips: - Feed twice daily rather than leaving food out all day. - Measure portions rather than estimating. - Keep treats and extras to roughly 10% or less of daily calories. - Aim for a visible waist when viewed from above and ribs you can feel without pressing hard. - Transition to new food gradually over 7–10 days to reduce digestive upset. PubMed Central (PMC)+1 [Unanswered follow-up prompt or questionnaire omitted; no selections submitted.] [Capture note: Full settled rendered HTML, DOM, native Copy, tables and screenshot archived. One submission, no follow-ups or questionnaire selections. Tables/cards preserved where native Copy omits them. Retailers, publishers, source labels, image credits and suggested prompts excluded from scoring. Mention frequency includes qualified and negative discussion, including unverified recall assertions; it is not endorsement. All veterinary, nutrition, WSAVA/AAFCO, health, allergy, feeding, safety, recall and price statements are captured unverified model output, not RecoScope guidance or established facts.]
Frequently Asked Questions