Benchmark Brief · 54 seconds
11 mentions. A split first choice.
Protein Powder · Collected
Benchmark Brief · 54 seconds
Protein Powder · Collected
12 usable answers · Four AI assistants · Three prompt types
Optimum Nutrition appeared in 11/12 usable answers; Transparent Labs and Dymatize each appeared in 7/12. Comparative first choice split evenly: ChatGPT and Claude ranked Transparent Labs first; Gemini and Perplexity ranked Optimum Nutrition first. Mention frequency and comparative rank are separate measures.
The same US strength-training and desk-job profile was repeated across three fresh prompt types: discovery, everyday budget under $50 and comparative ranking. Optimum Nutrition, Dymatize and Orgain appeared in all four budget answers. Mentions do not verify an under-$50 checkout price, availability or one agreed formula. Gemini named Dymatize Elite whey while the other budget answers named ISO100; Perplexity described its Orgain listing as out of stock.
These findings describe captured answers, not product quality or nutrition advice. Certification, purity, digestion and price claims remain unverified model output. Perplexity automatically enabled a free advanced-search preview on discovery. The November 9 and November 17 captures are descriptive snapshots, not a controlled improvement claim.
Compare the AI answers, prompts and recorded ranks.
Captured answers, not product-quality ratings.
Read along
Prefer reading? Here’s the narration in full.
Eleven mentions. But first choice split in two.
In Recoscope’s November seventeenth protein powder benchmark, Optimum Nutrition appeared in eleven of twelve usable answers. Transparent Labs and Dymatize each appeared in seven.
In the comparative prompt, ChatGPT and Claude ranked Transparent Labs first. Gemini and Perplexity ranked Optimum Nutrition first.
Same strength-training and desk-job profile. Four AI assistants. Three prompt types: discovery, under fifty dollars, and ranking.
Optimum Nutrition, Dymatize and Orgain appeared in every budget answer. But brand mentions don’t verify an under-fifty-dollar checkout price, and the exact formulas varied.
Visibility and comparative rank are separate measures. These findings describe captured answers, not product quality.
Explore benchmark at getrecoscope.com.
Optional closed captions are available in the player and off by default, so they don’t overlap the on-screen captions.