AI benchmark ·
Seasonal weekly benchmark — May 24, 2026
Lawn Fertilizer
Research by Robert Hu · Published by RecoScope · Collected
Milorganite and Scotts appeared in 12 of 12 answers each.
- Mention frequency
- Milorganite / Scotts12/12usable answers each · tied
- First-place ranks
- Scotts2/4ranked comparisons
12 usable answers · 4 assistants · 3 prompt types
ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity
Compare the AI answersCaptured answers, not a product-quality score.
- Usable answers
- 12/12
- Models
- 4
- Prompt types
- 3
Included: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity
Research by Robert Hu · Published by RecoScope
Report history · May 24 selected · 12 snapshots
Key takeaway
For a suburban DIY homeowner, AI routes overwhelmingly to Scotts and Milorganite first, with The Andersons the premium step-up. The trackable signal is Lesco: it surfaces only in Gemini (ranked #1 in Gemini's brand-comparison prompt for the second run running), though across all of Gemini's prompts its aggregate top pick is Milorganite. Lesco is the only brand any model elevates to a #1 slot in any prompt besides the Scotts-Milorganite-Andersons core. A brand outside that core is effectively invisible at purchase intent unless the buyer names it.
Which brands appear?
Usable answers containing each brand, counted once per answer. Includes unranked and critical mentions. Compare recommendation ranks in the AI rankings section.
12 brands recorded in this snapshot. Counts are usable answers, not recommendation ranks.
How to read the labels
Dropped this week
Who ranks first in each AI answer?
Recorded top-three ranks from the comparative prompt (Prompt 3). A mention alone does not imply a rank or establish product quality.
4/4 models with recorded ranks
ChatGPT
- #1
- Scotts
- #2
- Pennington
- #3
- Milorganite
Claude
- #1
- Scotts
- #2
- Milorganite
- #3
- The Andersons
Gemini
- #1
- Lesco
- #2
- Milorganite
- #3
- Scotts
Perplexity
- #1
- The Andersons
- #2
- Scotts
- #3
- Jonathan Green
| Agent | #1 | #2 | #3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| ChatGPT | Scotts | Pennington | Milorganite |
| Claude | Scotts | Milorganite | The Andersons |
| Gemini | Lesco | Milorganite | Scotts |
| Perplexity | The Andersons | Scotts | Jonathan Green |
Historical parsing conventions may differ; use the captured answers and collection notes when comparing snapshots.
What This Means
- All four models keep Scotts and Milorganite as the core but diverge on the aggregate #1: the rendered table computes ChatGPT's top pick as The Andersons (it leads ChatGPT's P1 discovery list), Gemini's as Milorganite, and Claude's and Perplexity's as Scotts.
- ChatGPT is commerce-formatted, surfacing 8-plus price-tagged SKUs and elevating The Andersons and Yard Mastery in discovery before ranking Scotts #1 in its explicit brand-ranking prompt.
- Claude is premium-leaning, repeatedly elevating The Andersons PGF Complete and uniquely surfacing Lesco and Simple Lawn Solutions.
- Gemini is lifestyle-formatted and, for the second consecutive run, ranks Lesco 24-0-11 #1 in its brand-comparison (P3) prompt specifically - the only model to put Lesco at the top of any prompt - even though its all-prompt aggregate lands on Milorganite.
- Perplexity is the most consolidated, ranking The Andersons #1 in its brand-ranking prompt while keeping Scotts and Milorganite as the safe core.
Explore mention history Coverage and model changes can affect comparisons.
Mention Frequency Trend
Brands ordered by mention count in each run. Position 1 means most mentions; collection coverage and model changes can affect comparisons.
Scroll sideways to see all dates and labels.
Findings and Limitations
- The category is a tight Scotts-Milorganite duopoly at the top with a fragmented challenger tier.
- Lesco appears only in Gemini (but as its #1, twice running).
- Yard Mastery, GreenView, Sunday, and Expert Gardener each appear in a single model.
- Major brands with retail presence are absent this run: LawnStar, BioAdvanced, Spectracide, Ironite, Sta-Green, Vigoro, Dr.
- Earth, and Sunniland (several of which appeared in prior runs and have dropped).
- No model surfaced a clear sub-$15 budget winner with cross-model agreement, and the organic tier beyond Milorganite (Espoma, Dr.
- Earth, Down to Earth) remains thinly and inconsistently represented.
Recurring themes in the answers
- The brands AI favors share nitrogen-forward NPK ratios (32-0-4, 24-0-11, or similar) suited to established lawns, slow-release formulations cited as the lower-burn-risk default, added iron as the deep-green differentiator, and wide big-box availability (the explicit reason Scotts wins ease-of-use).
Inspect the captured answers
Saved response text is model output. Product and health claims are unverified. Tables and cards may be transcribed as text; source labels can remain. Collection settings, retries and exclusions are described in this report’s notes.
ChatGPT · Prompt 1Usable answer
Best lawn fertilizer, 42yo suburban homeowner wants lawn looking its best
ChatGPT P1: Top pick The Andersons PGF Complete 16-4-8 ($69.88, best overall, N+K+iron+fine particles). Ranked list: The Andersons PGF Complete, Yard Mastery Flagship 24-0-6 ($39.99 dark green), Scotts Green Max ($68.49 fast greening), Milorganite 6-4-0 ($24.99 organic slow-release), GreenView with GreenSmart ($49.98 value), Jonathan Green Veri-Green ($59.99 premium), Espoma Organic ($46.02 eco), Pennington UltraGreen ($14.99 budget). Best quick green Scotts/Yard Mastery, best organic Milorganite, best big-box Scotts/Pennington. Soil test first, feed 2-4x/year.
Claude · Prompt 1Usable answer
Best lawn fertilizer, 42yo suburban homeowner wants lawn looking its best
Claude P1: Best overall Scotts Green Max (fast greening + iron, widely available). Best organic Milorganite 6-4-0 (zero burn, slow release, gentle for fescue summer). Best professional Lesco 24-0-11 (pro top pick, ~$4/1000sqft, SiteOne). Best spring The Andersons PGF Complete 16-4-8 (4-1-2 ratio + iron + Humic DG, slow+quick release). Personal rec: Milorganite for forgiving no-burn or Lesco for pro results. Soil test, early fall + late spring, 3-5 apps/year.
Gemini · Prompt 1Usable answer
Best lawn fertilizer, 42yo suburban homeowner wants lawn looking its best
Gemini P1: 1 Best overall dark green Milorganite 6-4-0 (cult favorite, slow-release organic, impossible to burn, 2.5% iron, no growth surge). 2 Best premium hybrid The Andersons Innova 7-1-2 (golf-course brand, 100% plant-derived, soil-microbe digestible, safe kids/pets). 3 Best quick green-up Scotts Turf Builder UltraFeed (benchmark, polymer-coated, feeds 3x longer). Check NPK ratio, soil test, know grass type, water it in.
Perplexity · Prompt 1Usable answer
Best lawn fertilizer, 42yo suburban homeowner wants lawn looking its best
Perplexity P1: Default slow-release nitrogen-forward. Best overall Scotts Turf Builder Lawn Food or Milorganite (fast cosmetic vs gentler organic). Best convenience/greening Scotts Turf Builder. Best low-risk organic-style Milorganite (slow-release, non-burning, iron). Best if weeds Scotts Turf Builder Triple Action / Weed & Feed. Start Milorganite if you prefer forgiving, or Scotts Turf Builder simplest mainstream. ~1 lb N per 1000 sqft.
Frequently Asked Questions